Card Supply Co. Monthly Mystery Box

Monthly subscription · Factory sealed

The Monthly Mystery Box

$199/mo$275+ guaranteed market valueShips the 1st

A hand-picked mix of factory-sealed English Pokémon TCG — booster boxes, Elite Trainer Boxes, bundles, collections and packs — with an itemized packing slip showing the market price of everything inside. Free U.S. shipping. Cancel anytime online.

This month’s bonus

This month’s bonus: a PSA 10 Roaring Moon ex SIR (≈$700) for one random entrant.

Every active subscriber is entered automatically, one entry per person. It’s a graded single on top of the $275+ guaranteed sealed value. Entries close October 25, 2026 at 11:59 PM PT.

The value math

What you pay vs. what you get

You pay$199/mo
Guaranteed market value$275+

That’s $76+ above what you pay, at market prices on packing day. Market value = TCGplayer market prices on the day we pack your box. It’s a reference point for what the product sells for, not a promise of what you could resell it for.

How it works

Three steps. Real dates.

Dates shown in Pacific time and update daily.

  1. 01

    Join today

    You’re charged $199 + tax now and your first box ships within 1–3 business days.

  2. 02

    Join by Oct 25 → next box ships Nov 1

    Your next charge is November 1, 2026, then the 1st of every month.

  3. 03

    Skip, update or cancel online

    Every email has your private manage link. Skip a month, change your address or card, or cancel — no fees, no minimum.

What’s inside

Sealed product only

  • A mix of booster boxes, Elite Trainer Boxes, booster bundles, collections and booster packs
  • Factory-sealed, English-language Pokémon TCG — never opened, weighed, searched or resealed
  • Never singles, never opened or repacked product
  • Packed box-in-box with tracking

Contents vary each month. We can’t promise particular products, sets or pulls — only sealed product that meets the value guarantee.

This month’s bonus is a graded single (the PSA 10 Roaring Moon ex), in addition to the $275+ guaranteed sealed value. It doesn’t count toward the guarantee.

The guarantee

$275+ or we make it right

  • At least $275 combined TCGplayer market value, priced on packing day
  • Itemized packing slip with the market price of every item
  • If a box is ever under $275, we make up the difference in product or store credit
  • Damaged or not as described? Photos within 7 days → replacement or refund

Market value = TCGplayer market prices on the day we pack your box. It’s a reference point for what the product sells for, not a promise of what you could resell it for. Mystery boxes are otherwise final sale.

Subscribe

Contact
Ship to (U.S. only)
Card

Your card is saved securely by GoDaddy Payments for monthly renewals. We never see or store your card number.

Automatic renewal terms

  • $199.00 + applicable sales tax charged today, then automatically on the 1st of every month until you cancel.
  • Cancel anytime online with the manage link in every email (or at /subscription). Cancelling stops future charges immediately. No fees, no minimum.
  • Final sale except damage / not as described. See the Subscription policy.

By subscribing you agree to our Terms and Subscription policy.

This month’s bonus: a PSA 10 Roaring Moon ex SIR (≈$700) for one random entrant. Subscribers are entered automatically until Oct 25.

Good to know

Mystery Box FAQ

Subscription policy
How do I cancel?

Online, anytime, in two clicks — use the manage link in any of our emails, or request it at /subscription with your email. Cancelling stops all future charges immediately; a box you’ve already paid for still ships. No fees, no minimum.

Can I skip a month?

Yes. Use your manage link to skip the next box before its billing date — you won’t be charged that month, and you can undo it.

What is the 25th cutoff?

Join by the 25th (Pacific time) and your next box is billed and ships on the 1st of next month. Join after the 25th and your first box still ships right away, but your next charge moves to the 1st of the month after — so you’re never charged twice within a few days.

When am I charged?

When you join ($199 + any sales tax), then on the 1st of every month until you cancel. We email a reminder about 6 days before each renewal and a receipt after.

Shipping?

Free, U.S. addresses only. Boxes ship on or right after the 1st with tracking (your first box ships within 1–3 business days of joining).

What’s the $275 guarantee exactly?

Every box contains factory-sealed English Pokémon TCG product with a combined TCGplayer market value of at least $275 on the day we pack it, and the packing slip lists every item with its market price. If a box is ever under $275, we make up the difference in product or store credit. Market value = TCGplayer market prices on the day we pack your box. It’s a reference point for what the product sells for, not a promise of what you could resell it for.

Returns?

Mystery boxes are final sale. If anything arrives damaged or isn’t as described, email photos within 7 days of delivery and we’ll replace or refund it.

Will I get the same thing every month?

We vary the mix month to month and keep track of what we’ve sent you. We can’t promise specific products, sets or pulls — just sealed English product meeting the value guarantee.